DOJ-OGR-00019401.pdf

Case 20-3061, Document 60, 09/24/2020, 2938278, Page2 of 58 Table of Contents Table of Contents .......................................................i Table of Authorities ......................................................iii Statement of the Case and the Facts .......................................1 The indictment ...............................................................1 The civil case ................................................................1 The subpoena ................................................................2 The order declining to modify the criminal protective order ........8 The appeals ....................................................................9 Jurisdictional Statement......................................................10 Issue Presented ...............................................................22 Summary of the Argument ...................................................22 Argument.......................................................................23 I. Judge Nathan erred in refusing to modify the protective order for the limited purpose of allowing Ms. Maxwell to share with Judge Preska, under seal, material information .......................23 A. Preservation and standard of review ...............................26 B. The district court erred in declining to modify the protective order.......26 Conclusion .....................................................................33 Certificate of Compliance with Rule 32(A)...............................35 Certificate of Service.......................................................35