EFTA02647144.pdf
dataset_11 pdf 481.9 KB • Feb 3, 2026 • 4 pages
From: jeffrey E. <jeevacation@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, June 20, 2017 4:28 PM
To: Nowak, Martin
<http://www.bgci.org/templates/org_bgci/images/members-area=jpg> <https://members.bgci.org>
Member's Area
<http://www.bgci.org/templates/org_bgci/images/plant-search=jpg> <http://www.bgci.org/plant_search.php>
PlantSearch
<http://www.bgci.org/templates/org_bgci/images/threat-searc=.jpg> <http://www.bgci.org/threat_search.php>
ThreatSearch
<http://www.bgci.org/templates/org_bgci/images/globaltree-s=arch.jpg>
<http://www.bgci.org/global_tree_search.php>
GlobalTreeSearch
<http://www.bgci.org/templates/org_bgci/images/garden-searc..jpg> <http://www.bgci.org/garden_search.php>
GardenSearch
<http://www.bgci.org/templates/org_bgci/images/cultivate.jp=> <http://www.bgci.org/news-and-
events/ournewsletter/>
Sign up to Cultivate
Receive news and updates
Resource centre > Darwin the botani=t
Darwin the botanist
Volume 5 Number 2 - October 2008
David Kohn
French title: Darwin le botaniste
Spanish title: Darwin el=botanico
EFTA_R1_01884870
EFTA02647144
Summary
In his theory of evolution, Charles Darwin proposed that living beings were "all netted together" through a common
ancestry. Yet o=e branch of the tree of life, the plant kingdom, was Darwin's most enduring foc=s. He was a major field
collector, a consummate and sustained observer of plant life, a rigorous botanical experimentalist, and the high theorist
of plant evolution.
Botany played a pivotal part in each phase of Darwin's life. As an undergraduate, he collected=20 specimens for his
botany professor's herbarium while on a geologica= expedition in Wales. Voyaging for five years aboard the HMS
Beagle= he collected plants along with fossil bones and bird skins. Preparing to =rite On the Origin of Species, botany
became critical to the growth of his evolutionary theory. Ultimately, he turned his home and the surrounding
countryside into a botanical field station.
Darwin's six botan=cal books would recast large areas of plant science. His studies on the fertilization of orchids, on
insectivorous plants, and on the climbing and other plant movements were each a beautifully articulate example of how
evolution could solve the traditional mysteries of natural history. Through his work, Darwin laid foundations for modern
botany that remain firm to this day.
Darwin's botanical formation
Darwin was heir to a rich botanical tradition, one that often resonated in the specific botanical topics and viewpoints he
was to adopt. His grandfather Erasmus Darwin, for example, was an evolutionist and spread the Linnaean doctrine that
plants, just like animals, have sexes. Darwin's first botanical exposure was in his father's ample=garden at The Mount in
Shrewsbury where young Charles played among apple trees bred by Thomas Andrew Knight, President of the Royal
Horticultural Society. However, the foundations of Darwin's formal education in b=tany were laid at Cambridge by his
dynamic professor John Stevens Henslow (1796-1861) who later opened the way for Darwin to participate in the
B=agle's scientific cruise around the world.
The Beagle =oyage
The Beagle expedition concentrated on certain regions of South America: coastal Brazil, Patagonia, Tierra del Fuego, the
Andean coast as far north as Lima and the oceanic Galapagos archipelago.
Plants came before birds in the birth of Darwinian evolution. Darwin did not become an evolutionist on the Galapagos,
but the basis for a profound=20 shift in his understanding of species was established there — and i= began with plants.
When the Beagle arrived in the Galapagos i= September 1835, Darwin immediately observed that the flora appeared
unique. Thereupon, he collected "all the plants in flower".=This we know from a pocket field notebook that Darwin kept
when he was in the archipelago. Darwin's Galapagos plant specimens, numbering wel= over 200, constitute the single
most influential natural history collection of live organisms in the entire history of science. Indeed, Darwin'= plants
represent the foundational collection for the entire Galapagos=20 flora. Settled back in London in 1837, he sketched his
first evolutionary tree and began firmly applying the idea of descent with modification to all of natural history.
In 1856, D=rwin put ink to blue foolscap and began to steadily write. His seminal boo=, On the Origin of Species, was
finally published in November 185=.
2
EFTA_R1_01884871
EFTA02647145
Preserving priority
Once the Origin<=em> was published, botany became the central focus of Darwin's researc= for the remaining years of
his life. This botanical work was highly original, not only because of the quality of his observations, but because it was
the first attempt to apply the principles of evolution to plants.
Darwin's crucial contribution to b=tany was his understanding of and ability to demonstrate that the flower is a product
of evolution. By the 18th century, botanists were convinced that flowering plants have both male and female parts, and
assumed that most plants self fertilise or inbreed. This erroneous and deeply ingrained view of the flower continued
until Darwin began publishing on the biological meaning of flowers in the 1860s. The prevalence of cross-pollination was
Darwin's single most important botanical trut=.
Indeed Darwin realised there was a problem with plant sex immediately after discovering natural selection in 1838. If
flowers perpetually self fertilised then both natural selection and evolution would be invalid, because natural selection
requires hereditary variation. If there is no variation, there is simply nothing to select. Evolution stops. If flowers self
fertilised for generation after generation, they would become unvarying clones. Furthermore, without variation, where
did the thousands of known plant species come from? Evolution would not explain the diverse families of flowering
plant genera and species. The world =99s flowers were just too big a part of nature for Darwin to forfeit them to the
creationist position that species are immutable.
In the case of flowers, he undertook decades of field and garden observations and breeding experiments, all focused on
testing and supporting one powerful hypothesis: that of natural selection.
Through his painstaking studies, such as the Primula =xample below, Darwin discovered that flowering plants have
evolved elaborate structures, strategies, and relations with animals and reasoned that it was all to avoid the apparent
necessity of perpetual inbreeding. Thus the Darwinian meaning of flowers became a pillar of botany and botany became
one of the strongest fields supporting evolution.
Love, Primu=a style
Spring 1860 was the first flowering seaso= following Origin's publication. Darwin, bursting with experimental energy,
made several crucial botanical discoveries. In May, he observed two different kinds of flowers among common primulas.
The style, or shaft of the female part, is either tall, protruding like a pin, or it is short. Darwin's chi=dren gathered
armloads of flowers for their father, who noticed something: The two kinds of flower occur in a 50:50 ratio. To explain
these two morphs, Darwin would follow the scientific method, but after his very own personal style. At first, the 50:50
ratio reminded him of a normal male-female sex ratio. So he believed the two kinds of flowers were evolving into
separate sexes. That is, he thought he had witnessed one step in the evolution of separate male and female flowers. The
tall-style flowers must be evolving into pure females, he surmised. Conversely, their short stamens must be losing
potency. To test this he crossed the two forms. But to his surprise, the 'males' pro=uced abundant seeds. So the
experimental method forced him to abandon his first hypothesis. As Darwin once observed, his first explanations of
things frequently proved wrong. The originality and breakthrough would come with thinking up the next explanation.
He now realised that the maximum fertility occurs when pollen moves from one form to the other. It was always the self
fertilised flowers that had reduced fertility. Thus the two forms, each of which is both male and female, are favoured to
maintain a stable population. Darwin had in fact discovered a breeding strategy that gave a clear advantage to cross-
pollination and thus provided experimental support for his long-held interpretation of the meaning of flowers. To think
of flowers in terms of plant breeding strategies, now that is evolutionary botany. And Darwin's primulas have been a
prime example of this new way of=20 thinking ever since.
3
EFTA_R1_01884872
EFTA02647146
Plant sensitivity: green adaptations
Plants don't have feet and they also don't have brains. But as fa= as Darwin was concerned, some plants as good as have
eyes, and they do have behaviour, often expressed in the extraordinary ways these beings can move despite being
rooted in the soil. Darwin's passion for working=out the botanical adaptations that allow plants to stay in sensitive touch
with their environment occupied him for years in physiological experiments that prefigure the biochemical and cellular
studies of the early 20th century on enzymatic catalysis and plant hormones. Thus these green adaptations in leaves and
stems not only paralleled Darwin's=20 flowers, they added a new level of sophistication to the botanical bulwarks
Darwin had built to support evolution and adaptation by natural selection. For example, insectivorous plants that trap
and digest insects with specialised leaves fascinated Darwin. So did vines that climb up and over other plants. He saw
plants as sensitive creatures whose growing tips or leaves or seedlings can track the movement of the sun. Indeed, he
showed they could respond to the least beam of incident light, the pull of gravity, and the slight touch of a browsing
animal.
M=ch of this work Darwin performed in a string of hothouses that gradually sprang up along the kitchen garden wall
beginning in the late 1850s. Eventually, there were five houses heated by a boiler and offering a fair range of conditions
for the array of plants that Darwin, assisted in his last years by his son Francis, wished to study.
=C2 please note
The information contained in t=is communication is confidential, may be attorney-client privileged, ma= constitute
inside information, and is intended only for the use of =he addressee. It is the property of JEE Unauthorized use,
disclosure=or copying of this communication or any part thereof is strictly prohib=ted and may be unlawful. If you have
received this communication in =rror, please notify us immediately by return e-mail or by e-mail to
jeevacation@gmail.c=m, and destroy this communication and all copies thereof, includ=ng all attachments. copyright -all
rights reserved
--001a1144a5443c3247055266bcb6-- conversation-id 40802 date-last-viewed 0 date-received 1497976081 flags
8590195713 gmail-label-ids 7 remote-id 722783
4
EFTA_R1_01884873
EFTA02647147
Entities
0 total entities mentioned
No entities found in this document
Document Metadata
- Document ID
- dab10c94-01f0-4c73-ab6c-a846a4a2bf5e
- Storage Key
- dataset_11/EFTA02647144.pdf
- Content Hash
- be23cc498b856058bfde8d96fe020183
- Created
- Feb 3, 2026