EFTA01158671.pdf

OQS - Viewing Cese Number 98041883 Page 1 ut 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE CASE NO. 9804/883 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. DISPOSITION: INACTIVE DIVISION: ROAD PATROL CONFIDENTIAL SEXUAL BATTERY SIGNAL CODE: 35 CRIME CODE: 1 NON CRIME CODE: CODE: 110A 02/28/98 SATURDAY ZONE: B71 GRID: WPB DEPUTY Z.D.: 3257 NAME: BORES DAVID ASSIST: TIME D 1603 A 1618 OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 02/28/98 , 1630 HOURS AND DATE: 0000 HOURS EXCEPTION TYPE: INCIDENT LOCATION: 1000 LANZ AV APT. NO.: CITY: LANZ WORTH STATE: FL ZIP: 33460 NO. OFFENSES: 01 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEHICLES STOLEN: 0 NO. PREMISES ENTERED: 0 LOCATION: PARK / WOODLANDS / FIELD NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0 WEAPON TYPE: HANDS / FISTS / FEET OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 794 011 CIS CODE 110A NAME LIST: ROLE: COMPLAINANT CAROL J CROTEAD DOB: 12/28/1964 SEX: F RACE: W HT: 504 WT: 135 BR: BROWN LYE: GREEN RESIDENTIAL ADDRESS: 1362 DAVIS RD WPB FL 33406 ROME PRONE:SE BUSINESS ADDRESS: 1000 LAKE AVENUE, LW, FL 33460 BUSINESS PRONE:561 585-0892 AARESTEE JOSHUA B BUNNER DOH: 10/02/1979 SEX: M RACE: W HT: 601 WIT: 155 RR: BLOND EYE: BLUE OFFENSE INDICATOR: OFFENSE I VICTIM NUMBER: 1 VICTIM TYPE: JUVENILE RESIDENCE TYPE: COUNTY RESIDENCE STATUS: FULL YEAR EXTENT OP INJURY: NONE INJURY TYPE(1): NOT APPLICABLE INJURY TYPE(2): NOT APPLICABLE VICTIM RELATION: ACQUAINTANCE Ireintod by *ploys. Id I, 4541 ea Yebniazy 07, 2007 01 EXHIBIT hn p://tup. phso.org/indcx .cfm?th stdspeasc& fm °wee= I &srht a=4bldb1 I c2888a25i 6 EFTA01158671  Page 2 of 20 OQS - Viewing Case Number 08041883 BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE PALM OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. CASE ND. 98041883 DISPOSITION: INACTIVE REPORT NUMBER: 1 FLORIDA VICTIM ? N WEATHER: CLODDY WITNESS TO CRIME KNOWN ?. N SUSPECT NAME KNOWN ? SUSPECT LOCATION KNOWN ? N CAN VICTIM I.D. SUSPECT ? I WILL VICTIM PROSECUTE ? Y STOLEN PROPERTY TRACEABLE ? N N EVIDENCE LEFT AT SCENE 7 N IS M.O. SIGNIFICANT SUSPECT'S VEHICLE KNOWN ? N LATENTS LIFTED ' TAG NUMBER KNOW ? PROPERTY DAMAGE AL LOCATION ON 2/28/98 AT 1600 HOURS I RESPONDED TO A CONFIDENTI REFERENCE A COMPLAINTOF SEXUAL BATTERY. UPON ARRIVAL I MET WITH THE ON-DUTY COUNSELOR, WHITE FEMALE, STATED, EARLIER IN THE DAY SEE LEARNED FROM RAPED APPROXI- ONE OF THE OCCUPANTS OF THE GROUP ROME THAT THE OCCUPANT WAS E. MATELY THREE AND A HALF WEEKS AGO AT AN UNKNOWN LOCATION IN LOXAHATCHE IDENTIFIED THE VICTIM AS WHITE FEMALE, . I THEN MET WITH , WHO STATED TEAT APPROXIMATELY THREE AND A MICH IS IN THE RALF WEEKS AGO SHE WAS PICKED UP FROM HER BOYFRIEND'S HOUSE CITY OP ROYAL PRIM BEACH, FLORIDA), BY TWO WHITE MALE ACQUAINTAN CES OF HERS. STATED THAT BOTH WERE IN THEIR TWENTIES. REFUSED TO PROVIDE IDENTIFICATION OR A DESCRIPTION OF THE TWO WRITE MALES. STATED THAT SHE WAS DRIVEN BY THE TWO WHITE MALES TO A WOWED ALCOHOL AREA SOIONWHERE IN LOXARATCHEE. SHE ALSO STATED THAT THEY ALL CONSUMED AND SMOKED MARIJUANA, AND THAT WAS INTOXICATED DURING THIS INCIDENT. STATED ONCE THE VEHICLE WAS PARKED IN THE WOODED AREA, BOTH WHITE MALES BAD FORCED SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH • STATED SHE DID RESIST BOTH WHITE MALES BY STATING TO THEM, NO. STATED AFTER THE SEXUAL INTERCOURSE, ONE OF THE WHITS MALES WAS AT DROPPED OFF, AND SHE WENT ROME WITH THE OTHER WHITE MALE TO HIS RESIDENCE AN UNENOWN LOCATION. STATED ONCE IN THE BEDROOM Or THE RESIDENCE, ONCE AGAIN THE WHITE MALE HAD FORCED SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH HER. STATED THAT SHE WAS NOT INJURED AS A RESULT. WHEN ASKED ONCE AGAIN TO PROVIDE INFORMATION ON THE IDENTITY OR THE DESCRIPTION OF THE SUSPECTS, SHE REFUSED. SGT. ST. CYR, ID 359, WAS NOTIFIED WOULD AND RESPONDED. THE DETECTIVE BUREAU WAS NOTIFIED. THEY STATED THEY REFERENCE THIS CASE CASE INFORMATIO N WAS GIVEN. THE CONDUCT A FOLLOW-UP DISPOSITION IN THIS CASE WILL BE CLASSIFIED AS INACTIVE PENDING FURTHER printed by satpleyee Id Ii 4341 cro rimbruarr 07, 2001 02 2/7/2007 htm://oqs.pbso.orgibulex.cfmgfa=dspease&fromrcc -1&srhtaa4bldbl 1c2888a25e-9D2CA17... EFTA01158672 OQS - Viewing Case Number 98041883 Page 3 of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE CASE NO. 98041883 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. DISPOSITION: INACTIVE INVESTIGATIVE LEADS. END OF NARRATIVE. D/S D. BURES/ID 3257/TRANS: 3/3/98/Ps/00543 DICT: 2/28/98/1730 HRS. OSIotod by Stoploye0 Id O: 4541 on Pobroos2 07, 2007 OS. Entp://oqs.pbso.org/index.cfm?fa •dspCasc&fromrec-' 2/7/2007 EFTA01158673 OQS - Viewing Case Number 98041883 Page 4 of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE CASE NO. 90041863 SUPPLEMENT 1 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. DISPOSITION: OPEN DIV/SION: DETECTIVE CONFIDENTIAL SEXUAL BATTERY SIGNAL CODE. CRIME CCDE: NMI CRIME CODE: CODE: 210A 03/31/98 SATURDAY ZONE: 871 GRID: DEPUTY I.D.: 3553 NAME: ARNOLD ASSIST: TIME D 1603 A 3.618 OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 02/28/98 , 1630 HOURS AND DATE: 0000 HOURS EXCEPTION TYPE: INCIDENT LOCATION: APT. NO.: CITY: STATE: ZIP: NO. OFFENSES: 01 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEHICLES STOLEN: 0 NO. PREMISES ENTERED: 0 LOCATION: PARK / WOODLANDS / FIELD NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0 WEAPON TYPE: HANDS / FISTS / FEET OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 794 011 CIS CODE 110A ON 3-12-98, I RECEIVED A CALL FROM INQUIRYING WHO WOULD BE INVESTIGATING HER DAUGHTER'S SEXUAL BATTERY INVESTIGATION, I CHECKED THE SIU LOG AND POUND THAT THE CASE HAD NOT BEEN ASSIGNED. I WAS NEXT UP ON THE CASE ROTATION LIST SO I ASSIGNED THE CASE TO MYSELF AS SGT. STORMES WAS OFF TOLD ME THAT HER DAUGHTER IS CURRENTLY RESIDING AT A CONFIDENTIAL LOCATION AND THAT I SHOULD CONTACT TO SPEAK WITH HER DAUGHTER. ON 3-13-98, I CALLED AT (CONFIDENTIAL LOCATION) TO SET UP AN INTERVIEW APPOINTMENT WITH IS NOT AVAILABLE AND I LEFT A MESSAGE FOR HER TO PLEASE CALL )42 BACK. ON 3-16-98. I RECEIVED A MESSAGE FROM . I CALLED HER BACK AND SHE WAS NOT AVAILABE. ON 3-17-98, I LEFT FOR A CONFERENCE IN HUNSTVILLE, ALABAMA AND DID NOT RETURN TO WORK UNTIL 3-23-98. ON 3-24-98, I AGAIN CALLED TO SET UP AN APPOINTMENT WITH AND WAS NOT AVAILABLE AND I LEFT A MESSAGE. ON 3-30-98 : WAS ABLE TO MA= CONTACT WITH AND WE SET CP AN INTERVIEW FOR ON 3-31-98 AT 2:30WW. BET. ARNOLD/3553 RAP/JESS/4213/4-21-98 pallabod Ay employs's Id 0: 4342 an rabzwory 07, 0007 SI. hup://oqs.ribso.orglindex.efm*?frdspeaso&fromree &srham4bldbI 1c2888a25e-9D2CAP.... 2/7/2007 EFTA01158674 OQS - Viewing Case Number 98041883 Page 5 of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE CASE NO. 98041883 SUPPLEMENT 2 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. DISPOSITION: OPEN DIVISION: DETECTIVE CONFIDENTIAL SEXUAL BATTERY • SIGNAL CODE: CRIME CODE: NON CRIME CODE: CODE: 110A 04/06/98 SATURDAY ZONE: 871 GRID: DEPUTY I.D.: 3553 NAME: ARNOLD ASSIST: TINE D 1603 A 1616 OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 02/28/99 , 1630 HOURS AND DATE• 0000 HOURS EXCEPTION TYPE: INCIDENT LOCATION: APT. NO.: CITY: STATE: ZIP: NO. OFFENSES: 01 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEHICLES STOLEN: 0 NO. PREMISES ENTERED: 0 LOCATION: PARK / WOODLANDS FIELD NO. V/CTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0 WEAPON TYPE: HANDS / FISTS / FEET OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 794 011 CIS CODE 110A ON 3-31-98 AT 3:00PM, I INITIATED A SWORN TAPED STATEMENT WITH IN REFERENCE TO A SEXUAL BATTERY INVESTIGATION. HAD A VERY QUIET DEMEANOR AND AT TIME SEEMED VERY RELUCTANT TO DISCUSS SENSITIVE FACTS ABOUT THIS CASE, WHICH IS NOT UNUSUAL. AT TIME WAS EMOTIONAL AND CRIED DURING THE INTERVIEW. SAID THAT SHE MET THE SUSPECTS FROM THIS INCIDENT AT A PARTY SEVERAL WEEKS PRIOR TO THE ASSAULTS, WHICH OCCURRED SCMETIME AROUND THE 1ST OF FEBRUARY. ON THE NIGHT OF THE ASSAULT, WAS AT HER BOYFRIEND'S HOUSE PLAYING VIDEO GAMES DOES NOT WANT TO DISCLOSE THE IDENTITY OF RIR BOYFRIEND AT THIS TINE), THE SUSPECTS PULLED UP TO BOYFRIEND'S ROUSE AT APPROXIMATELY 10:00PM ON THE OATS OF THE ASSAULT AND ASKED HIM IF HE WANTED TO GO OUT DRINKING. . BOYFRIEND COULD MOT GO, BUT HE TOLD THE SUSPECTS THAT WAS THERE THAT SHE HAD RUN AWAY. SUSPECTS CAME INSIDE OF THE RESIDENCE AND ASXED SHE WANTED TO GO DRINKING WITH THEN. AS STATED EARLIER. HAD MET THE SUSPECT BEFORE AND SEE SAID SHE FIGURED IT WOULD MEAN FREE DRINKS SO SHE DECIDED TO GO. SAID TEAT SHE AMS THE SUSPECTS DRANK FOR ABOUT FIFTEEN MINUTES AT HER BOYFRIEND'S HOUSE PRIOR TO LEAVING. SAID THAT SHE DRANK A FEW SHOTS OF EITHER TEQUILLA OR VODKA BEFORE THEY Lem ONCE IN THE CAR, SAID TEAT SHE HAD ABOUT FIVE BEERS AND SHE WENT OW TO TELL ME THAT SHE BECAME VERY DRUNK. I ASKED ' WHICH OF THE TWO SUSPECTS WAS DRIVING THE CAR AND SHE ps441400 by Nap2oyee Id II 4341 en 74breory 07, £004 01 hlip://eqs.pbso.orgiindex.cfinlirdspCase&tiennree--I &srlIta-Alb I dbI 1c2B88a25c-9D2CAlt... 2/7/2007 EFTA01158675 OQS - Viewing Case Number 98041883 Page 6 of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE CASE NO. 98041883 SUPPLEMENT 2 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. DISPOSITION: OPEN REPLIED "KEVIN" (UNKNOWN LAST NAME). SAID THAT SHE AND THE TWO SUSPECTS ARRIVED AT A WOODED AREA IN LOXANATCHEE CALLED "WOCOSIES". I ASKED FOR A DESCRIPTION OF 'S CAR AND SHE SAID THE CAR HAD "NORMAL SEATS" LIKE VELVET, WHICH INDICATES THEY PROBABLY WERE CLOTH SEATS. SAID THAT SHE DID NOT KNOW THE MARE OR MODEL OF THE CAR, BUT SHE SAID THAT IT WAS AN OLDER CAR, EITHER PURPLE OR MAROON IN COLOR DID NOT KNOW IF IT WAS A TWO DOOR OF FOUR DOOR OR ANY OTHER INFORMATION. I ASKED FOR A DESCRIPTION OF AND SHE SAID THAT HE IS A WHITE MALE, APPROXIMATELY TWENTY-THREE YEARS OF AGE, LONG BLONDE HAIR, MODERATELY OVERWEIGHT, APPROXIMATELY 5'11, WITH A DIRTY BLONDE GOATEE AND DIRTY BLONDE SIDEBURNS. SAID THAT THE SUSPECT NEVER MENTIONED A PLACE OF EMPLOYMENT OR JOB TYPE DURING THEIR CONVERSATION. AT THIS TIME SAID SHE DID NO? FEEL COMFORTABLE IDENTIFYING SUSPECT NUMBER 2 BECAUSE SHE IS CLOSE FRIENDS WITH HIS BROTHER AND SHE FEELS THIS WOULD JEOPARDIZE THAT FRIENDSHIP. AFTER ARRIVAL Al "TER WOODSIES" SAID THAT SHE PASSED OUT. WHEN SHE AWOKE, SHE WAS LYING ON THE FRONT SEAT OF WITH HER PANTS AROUND HER ANKLES AND SUSPECT NUMBER 2 (THE UNIDENTIFIED SUSPECT) ON TOP OF HER ENGAGING IS FORCED VAGINAL INTERCOURSE SAID THAT (SUSPECT 1) WAS ATTEMPTING TO FORCE NKR TO PERFORM ORAL. SEX ON HIM. SAID THAT THE SUSPECTS WOULD TAKE TURNS FORCING VAGINAL INTERCOURSE ON HER. I ASKED ABOUT SUSPECT NUMBER 1 FORCING ORAL SEE ON HER AS SHE PREVIOUSLY MENTIONED AND SHE SAID THAT HE FORCED THE READ OF HIS PENIS IN HER MOUTH SAID THAT SHE TOLD THE SUSPECTS THAT SHE WAS TIRED AND THAT SHE DID NOT WANT TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS ACTIVITY. WENT ON TO TELL ME THAT SHE WAS RAVING HER PERIOD DURING THE ASSAULT AND SHE REMEMBERS WAXING UP AND FINDING HER PANTS AROUND HER ANKLES AND SHE RAD A FEMININE PAD INSIDE OF HER SAID THAT SHE REFEMBERS TELLING THE SUSPECTS SOMETHING TO THE EFFECT OF "YOU'RE HAVING SEX WITH ME WHILE I'M ON HY PERIOD AND THAT'S GROSS". I ASKED IF THE SUSPECTS SAID ANYTHING WHILE THIS WAS HAPPENING AND SHE THEN SAID THAT SHE REMEMBERS THEM SAYING SOMETHING STUPID LIKE, ARE IOU HAVING FUN BABY ALSO WOULD LAUGH AND MAKE STUPID COMMENTS TO HER DURING THE ASSAULT. I ASKED IF EITHER OF THE SUSPECTS USED PROTECTION AND SHE SAID THEY DID NOT. WAS UNSURE IF EITHER OF THE SUSPECTS EJACULATED INSIDE OF HER. - ESTIMATED THAT THE ASSAULT PROBABLY LASTED AROUND FIVE TO SEVEN HOURS. REPORTED THAT (SUSPECT S1) FORCED SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH HER AT LEAST ONE TIME, BUT WAS UNSURE OF ANY ADDITIONAL ENCOUNTERS. SAID THAT SUSPECT 12 (UNIDENTIFIED SUSPECT) FORCED SEXUAL INTERCOURSE PP PP P PP .a• • PPPP • • •••• • prison by Ewan** Ed (14 4341 on 0,4bruory 07, 3007 01. ••• ••• •• ••• • •• •••••• I PO •••••••• • http://oqs.pbso.org/index.cfm7frdspCase& fromrce-l&srbtar4b1db11e28813425e-91)2CAE... 2/7/2007 EFTA01158676  Page 7 of 20 OQS - Viewing Case Number 98041883 BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S orrics PALM OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. CASE NO. 98041883 SUPPLEMENT 2 DISPOSITION: OPEN ON HER MORE THAN TWICE. AFTER THE ASSAULT IN THE WOODED AREA RETURNED WITH SUSPECT *2 INTERCOURS E WITH . SUSPECT #2 TO HIS RESIDENCE WHERE HE HAD SEXUAL THAT IT WAS HER TURN, (MEANING SHE WAS TO BE ON TOP DURING TOLD SEXUAL INTERCOURSE TOLD HIM SHE WAS TOO TIRED TO DO ANYTHING. TIME OF SAID THAT SUSPECT 42 PARENTS AND BROTHER WERE NOME AT THE ENCOUNTER AT HIS RESIDENCE. SAID THAT HER FRIEND (SUSPECT 42'S THE BROTHER) SAN KEA INSIDE OF THE RESIDENCE IN THE MORNING. I ASKED IF SHE TOLD ANYONE WHAT HAPPENED AND SHE SAID SHE TOLD HER BOYFRIEND THAT SHE HAD CONSENTED TO SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH THE SUSPECTS. I ASKED IF SHE GOT ALL OF HER CLOTHING AND PERSONAL ITEMS BACK FROM $ CAR. SHE SAID SHE IS MISSING A CLEAR PLASTIC EFFECTS. PURSE WITH BLACK TRIM WHICH CONTAINED MAKEUP AND OTHER PERSONAL DOES NOT REMEMBER IF ANT OF HER CLOTHES WERE LEFT IN CAR. IN CONCLUDING THE INTERVIEW, I ASKED IT ANYTHING ELSE HAPPENED I THAT WE DID NOT DISCUSS AND SHE SAID "THEY PERFORMED ORAL SEX ON ME". ASKED IF BOTH SUSPECTS DID THIS AND SHE REPLIED DID, I DON'T REMEMBER IF JOSH DID". WITH THAT LAST QUOTE, INADVERTENTLY IDENTIFIED SUSPECT NUMBER #2 AS JOSH. AT THE TIME MENTIONED JOSH'S NAME, SHE DID NOT REALIZE IT. I ASKED ABOUT THE BEER THE SUSPECTS GAVE HER AND SUE SAID THAT THEY GAVE HER FIVE BOTTLES OF BEER AND SHE SAID IT WAS EITHER MICHELOB OR BUSCH. I ASKED IF THE SUSPECTS GAVE HER ANY DRUGS AND SHE REPLIED "MARIJUANA". I ASKED HER WHO GAVE HER MARIJUANA AND SHE REPLIED "JOSH'. THEN REALIZED TEAT SHE HAD IDENTIFIED JOSH AS THE OTHER SUSPECT AID SPX BECAME VERY UPSET WITH HERSELF AND STARTED TO CRY. I ASKED HOW MUCH POT SHE SMOKED AND SHE SAID A COUPLE OF JOINTS. THIS CONCLUDED THE INTERVIEW AND I IN AGAIN AFTER THE INTERVIEW TO CONFIRM THAT ALL THE INFORMATION SHE HAD GIVER WAS THE TRUTH AND SHE SWORE THAT IT WAS. OW 4-1-98 AT 1515HRS, I SPOKE WITH ABOUT MY INTERVIEW WITH . I ASKED HER IF SEE COULD PROVIDE BOYFRIEND'S NAME AND SHE SAID TEAT SHE WOULD FIND HIS NAME AND CALL ME BACK. AT 1535HRS ON 4-1-98, YRS. CALLED ME BACK WITH BOYFRIEND' S NAME SAID HIS NAME IS TONY FIGUEROA AND HIS PHONE NUMBER IS 792-9076. MRS. ALSO SPOKE ABOUT HER DAUGHTER'S PAST DRUG ABUSE AND ALSO HOW MANY KIDS IN ROYAL PALM BEACH ARE INVOLVED IN DRUGS, WITCHCRAFT AND ANIMAL SACRIFICE. SAID THAT SHE HAS ATTEMPTED TO DISCUSS THE DRUG PROBLEM WITH THE PRINCIPAL AT ROYAL PALM • • • printed 1 Simplon* Id 0, 4541 cm Ifebrina-1 07, 2007 M. ..... • httplioqs.pbso.orgiindex.efinqfa=dspCase&fromrecr 1&srbtaa4bldbl I c2figga25e-0D2CAF.... 2M2007 EFTA01158677 OQS - Vicwing Casc Number 96041883 Page K of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE 2 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. CASE NO. 98041883 SUPPLEMENT DISPOSITION: 'mu IN CONVINCING BEACH HIGH SCHOOL AND SHE SAID THAT SHE RAS HAD LITTLE SUCCESS A PROBLEM. FURTHER FOLLOW UP INVESTIGAT ION ON THIS THE PRINCIPAL THERE IS CASE WILL BE FORTHCOMING, THRREPORC CASE REMAINS CLASSIFIED AS OPEN. DET. ARNOLD/3553 RAMIREZ/4213/4-21-98 Printing by MIg04 If 0: 4543 on Vibmagy 57, 2007 02. Ic2888a25e-9D2CAF... 217/2007 htM://ocis.pbso.org/index.cfrO fa udspeaso&fromrcc - I Barhta.,4bldb I EFTA01158678 OQS • Viewing Case Number 98041883 Page 9 of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE CASE NO. 98041883 SCPPLEMENT 3 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. DISPOSITION: OPEN DIVISION: DETECTIVE CONFIDENTIAL SEXUAL BATTERY • • SIGNAL CODE: CRIME CODE: NON CRIME coos: CODE: 110A 06/16/98 SATURDAY LONE: B71 GRID: DEPUTY I.D.: 3553 NAME: ARNOLD ASSIST: TINE D 1603 A 1628 OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 02/28/98 , 1630 HOURS AND DATE: 0000 HOURS EXCEPTION TYPE: INCIDENT LOCATION: APT. NO.: CITY: STATE: ZIP: NO. OFFENSES: 01 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEHICLES STOLEN: 0 NO. PREMISES ENTERED! 0 LOCATION: PARR / WOODLANDS i FIELD NO. VICTIMS: DI NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0 WEAPON TYPE: HANDS / FISTS / FEET OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 794 011 CIS CODE 110A INVESEIGAT:VE EFFORTS TO IDENTIFY THE LAST NAME OF SUSPECTS IN THIS CASE NAVE MET W:TH NEGATIVE RESULTS AT THIS TINE. IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT IT IS DIFFICULT TO MARE CONTACT WITH THE VICTIM BECAUSE SHE IS SOUSED AI, A CONFIDENTIAL LOCATION AND CALLS TO THE PATIENTS ARE STRICTLY LIMITED. FURTHER INVESTIGATION WILL BE FORTHCOMING. DET. ARNOID/3553 RAMIREZ/4213/6-29-98 • PrAstod UP 04Pbaree id do 4641 ee February 07, 200 7 02 . idtplioqs.pbso.orgimdex.cfm?la -adspease&frotnrec= 4tsrhts .4bl dblIc2888425e-9D2CAE... 2/72007 EFTA01158679 OQS - Viewing Case Number 98041853 Page 10 of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE SUPPLEMENT 4 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. CASE NO. 98041883 DISPOSITION: OPEN DIVISION: DETECTIVE CONFIDENTIAL SEXUAL BATTERY • CRIME CODE: NON CRIME CODE: CODE: 110A 07/31/98 SATURDAY SIGNAL CODE: ZONE; 871 GRID: DEPUTY I.D.: 3553 NAME: ARNOLD ASSIST: TIME D 1603 A 1618 OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 02/28/98 . 1630 HOURS AND DATE: 0000 HOURS EXCEPTION TYPE: INCIDENT LOCATION: APT. NO.: CITY: STATE: ZIP: 0 NO. OFFENSES: 01 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEHICLES STOLEN: 0 NO. PREMISES ENTERED: LOCATION: PARK / WOODLANDS / FIELD / FEET NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0 WEAPON TYPE: HANDS / FISTS OFFENSE NO. I FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 794 011 CIS CODE 110A WHILE CONDUCT/NG FOLLOW OP INVESTIGATION IN AN ATTEMPT TO OBTAIN THE LAST NAMES OF TEE SUSPECTS IN THIS CASE, I WAS REFERRED TO A SUBJECT BY THE NAME OF NICH)LAS SILVAGE AS THE PERSON WHO MIGHT KNOW THE LAST NAME OF A SUBJECT IDENTIFIED ONLY AS JOSH IN THE REPORT. ON 7-29-98, I RESPONDED TO THE MCDORALDS RESTAURANT IN ROYAL PALM BEACH WHERE I MADE CONTACT WITH NICHOLAS SILVAGE (7-6-81). I ASKED SILVAGE THAT IF HE WAS FAMILIAR WITH ANY SUBJECTS BY THE NAME OF JOSH. HE INDICATED JOAN HE KNEW A SUBJETT BY THE NAME or JOSH BONNER. SILVAGE INDICATED THAT WAS APPROXIMATELY EIGHTEEN YEARS OF AGE AND THAT HE IS APPROXIMATELY SAN DIEGO SIX FEET TALL. (SOLOS. PALMS SHOWS A LAST IQIOWN ADDRESS OF 15396 ATTEMPT TO DR. FOR JOSH'S BROTHER, NICHOLAS BONNER. EFFORST WILL HE MADE TO PRIOR TO LOCATE AND INTERVIEW JOSH RUNNER IN REGARDS TO THIS INVESTIGATION. AM ATTEMPTING TO OBTAIN A PHOTO OF HIM SO I SPEAKING TO BONNER THOUGH, I CAN PRESENT A PHOTO LINEUP TO THE VICTIM TO CONFIRM THAT THIS IS THE TO THE PERPETRATOR OF HER CRIME BEFORE HE IS INTERVIEWED IN REGARDS CASE ALLEGATIONS. FATHER INVESTIGATIVE LEADS WILL BE FORTHCOMING, THEREFORE REMAINS CLASSIFIED AS OPEN. DET. ARNOLD/3553 RAMIREZ/4213/8-5-98 . • P[inesd by Esployee Id 01.; 4541 co yebnary 07, 2007 01. E... 217/2007 hltp://oqs.pbso.org/index.elin?fa-dspCase/Cfrornrec= I &srina=4b 1db I I e2888825c-9D2CA EFTA01158680  Page 11 of 20 OQS • Viewing Case Number 98041883 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE OF REPORT CASE NO. CASE NO. 98041883 SUPPLEMENT 5 DISPOSITION! OPEN DIVISION: DETECTIVE CONFIDENTIAL d, • SEXUAL BATTERY WEDNESDAY CRIME OJOS: NON CRIME CODE: CODE: 110A 08/12/98 SIGNAL CODE; NAME: ARNOLD ASSIST: TIME D 1603 A 1618 ZONE: B71 GRID: DEPUTY I.D.: 3553 BETWEEN DATE: 02/28/98 , 1630 HOURS AND DATE: 0000 HOURS OCCURRED EXCEPTION TYPE: APT. NO.: INCIDENT LOCATION: CITY: STATE: ZIP: 0 NO. PREMISES ENTERED: 0 NO. OFFENSES: 01 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEHICLES STOLEN: LOCATION: PARK / WOODLANDS / FIELD HANDS / FISTS / FEET NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0 WEAPON TYPE: OFFENSE NO. I FLORIDA STATE STATUTE. 794 011 CIS CODE 110A • • TO to ON AUGUST 11, 1998 AT APPROXIMATELY 1800 HOURS, I RESPONDED CONFIDENTI AL LOCATION), WHERE I MADE CONTACT WITH I=MB IN EMIE IN REGARDS TO SHOWING HER A PHOTO LINEUP OF A POSSIBLE SUSPECT HER SEXUAL BATTERY CASE. I PRESENTED A PHOTO LINEUP CONTAINING SIX YOUNG WHITE WALES AND AND ASKED HER IF THE PERTETRATOR OF HER CRIME WAS IN THIS PHOTO LINEUP TMKEDIATELY BECAME EMOTIONALLY UPSET AND POINTED TO THE IT SHOULD BE NOTED SUBJECT IN THE NUMBER OUR POSITION OF THE PHOTO LINEUP. THAT THE SUBJECT IN POSITION NUMBER FOUR OF THE PHOTO LINEUP IS JOSHUA HAS MADE B. BUNKER (WHITE MALE, 10/02/79). BASED ON THE FACT THAT THE VICTIM IDENTIFICA TION THAT JOSH BUNKER IS ONE OP THE SUBJECTS THAT RAPED A POSITIVE AND CONDUCT HER ON OR ABOUT FEBRUARY 1, 1998, I WILL ATTEMPT TO LOCATE RUNNER IS AN INTERVIEW WITH HIM IN REGARDS TO THIS CASE. UNTIL SUCH TIME AS BONNER LOCATED AND AN INTERVIEW IS CONDUCTED. THE CASE WILL REMAIN CLASSIFIED AS OPEN. DST. BART ARNOLD ID #3553 TRANS. 08/17/96/DAW/13495 Printed by esployee id 9: 4541 on Yebeeedi 07. 2007 01. httplinqs.pbso.crgtindcx.etm?fa=dspease&fromrec=latsrhta-Abldblle2888025c-91)2CAti... 2/7/2007 EFTA01158681  Page 12 of 20 OQS - Viewing Case Number 98041883 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE 6 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. CASE NO. 5804/883 SUPPLEMENT DISPOSITION: OPEN DIVISION: DETECTIVE C ONFIDENTIAL SEXUAL BATTERY CRIME CODE: NON GRINE CODE: CODE: 110A OB/20/98 WEDNESDAY SIGNAL CODE: ASSIST: TIME D 1603 A 1618 ZONE! 871 GRID: DEPUTY I.D.: 3553 NAME: ARNOLD OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 02/28/98 , 1630 HOURS AND DATE: , 0000 HOURS EXCEPTION TYPE: APT. NO.: INCIDENT LOCATION: CITY: STATE: ZIP: NO. PREMISES ENTERED: 0 NO. OFFENSES: 01 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEHICLES STOLEN: 0 LOCATION: PARK / WOODLANDS / FIELD HANDS / FISTS / FEET NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0 WEAPON TYPE: OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 794 011 CIS CODE 110A AS REPORTED IN THE PREVIOUS SUPPLEMENT, MADE A POSITIVE IDENTIFICATION THAT JOSH BUNKER WAS ONE Of 1%2 SOBJECTS THAT SHOWED A RAPED HER ON/OR ABOUT MARCH 1ST, 1998. THE PESO PALMS COMPUTER CURRENT ADDRESS OF BONNER FOR 15396 SANDIEGO DR. IN LOXAHATCHEE. ON B-13-98, I RESPONDED TO THAT ADDRESS IN AN ATTEMPT TO MAKE CONTACT TO BE HONE. WITH BONNER. THERE WAS A LOCKED GATE AND NO ONE APPEARED I CONTACTED PESO DISPATCH TO SEE IF THEY COULD FIND A NUMBER FOR THE CARD RESIDENCE AND THIS MT WITH NEGATIVE RESULTS. 2 LEFT MY BUSINESS OFFICE. AT THE RESIDENCE WITH A NOTE TO HAVE JOSH CALL ME AT THE SHERIFF'S ON 8-17-98 AT APPPROXIMATELY 3:30PM, I AGAIN RESPONDED TO 15396 AND THIS SANDIEGO DR. IF AN ATTEMPT TO MEE CONTACT WITH JOSHUA BONNER WITH TIME I WAS SUCCESSFUL. I ASKED JOSH IF HE WOULD BE WILLING TO SPEAK AGREED TO ME IN REGARDS TO AN ONGOING SHERIFF'S OFFICE INVESTIGATION AND HE DO THIS. I TOLD JOSH THAT HE WAS NOT REQUIRED TO BE SUBJECT TO THIS TERMINATE THE INTERVIEW AND IF HE DECIDED TO CONDUCT THE INTERVIEW HE COULD SINNER INTERVIEW AT ANY TIME. PRIOR TO GOING ON TAPE, I ONLY ASKED JOSH ABOUT HIS FRIEND KEVIN AND ABOUT ANT TYPE OF HOBBIES THAT HE AND THOMSPON ENGAGE IN TOGETHER. OF AT 3:48PM. I INITIATED A TAPED INTERVIEW WITH JOSH BONNER INSIDE IN THE FRONT OF RUNNER'S RESIDENCE AT 15396 MY UNMARKED VEHICLE PARKED INTERVIEW ANY SANDIEGO DR. AGAIN, I TOLD JOSH THAT HE COULD TERMINATE THE THAT TIME THAT HE WANTED TO AND GO BACK INSIDE OF BIB HOUSE. JOSH SAID HZ UNDERSTOOD THIS. primes! by Sinn 7.1 0: 0241 00 Ilsbarry 07. 2007 01. 9D2CAE... 2/7/2007 http://ogs.pbso.org/indcz.cfm^fa dspease&fromree= I &srhta=4b1db 1 1 e2888a25e- EFTA01158682 OQS - Viewing Case Nwnber 98041883 Page 13 of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE CASE NO. 98041883 SUPPLEMENT 6 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. DISPOSITION, OPEN JOSH TOLD HE THAT HE HAS KNOWN FOR ABOUT TWO YEARS. I ASKED SUMNER IF HE KNEW A GIRL BY TEE NAME OF AND BE CONFIRMED THAT RE DID. I ASKED BUNKER HOW HE KNEWI=. AND HE SAID THAT NE KNEW HER AS A FRIEND AND HE WENT ON TO SAY TEAT THEY (BUNKER AND KEVIN THOMPSON) TOOK HER OUT DRINKING. I TOLD BONNER THAT HAD MADE ALLEGATIONS THAT SEXUAL ACTIVITY OCCURRED BETWEEN SHE, BUMMER AND THOMPSON AND THAT THIS SEXUAL ACTIVITY WAS NOT CONSENSUAL ON HER PART AND JOSH BANNER REPLIED ". I ASKED HIM IF IT WAS CONSENSUAL AND HE REPLIED RUNNER WENT ON TO TELL HE THAT THEY WERE DRINKING BEERS IN A WOODED AREA IN LOXABATCHEE CALLED THE WHOOPTIES. JOSH INITIALLY SAID TEAT HAD TWO OR TARES BEERS. JOSH ALSO SAID THAT WAS PLAYING LIKE SHE WAS GOING TO GO TO SLEEP WHILE THEY WERE IN THE WOODS. I ASKED JCSE RUNNER TO TELL ME EXACTLY NEAT HAPPENED THAT NIGHT AND HE ". I ASKED JOSH WHO RE MEANT BY SAYING WE RAD SEX AND HE REPLIED " ". REFERRING TO JOSH, AND . I ASKED JOSH SEERS THIS HAPPENED AND HE REPLIED / ASKED JCSK BUNKER ABOUT BIS SEXUAL ENCOUNTER WITH AND HE SAID - • I ASKED GUNNER IF HE USED ANY PROTECTION AND HE SAID THEY USED A CONDOM. I ASKED RUNNER IF HE OR WAS THE FIRST ONE TO HAVE SEX WITH AND HE SAID " I ASKED BCNMER HOW THE SEXUAL ACTIVITY GOT STARTED AND HE REPLIED JOSH SAID REPLIED JOSH SAID THAT SAID TO HIM SOMETHING TO THE EFFECT OF Will DON'T YOU KEEP ME AWAKE. I ASKED BUNKER IF THEY WERE ABLE TO KEEP AND HE SAID I ASKED RUNNER IF THERE WAS ANY TALK PRIOR TO THE ACTUAL SEXUAL ACTIVITY ABOUT THEM HAVING SEXUAL RELATIONS AND HE SAID THERE WAS NOT ANY TALK OF THAT. I ASKED RUNNER TO TELL ME EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED ABOUT HE AND ' RAVING SEX AND HE SAID "W I ASKED HIM WHERE THAT WAS AND HE REPLIED I ASKED RUNNER HOW THEY WERE POSITIONED AND HE SAID IT WAS HARD TO DESCRIBE. HE SAID TEAT KEVIN WAS IN THE DRIVER'S SEAT AND THAT HE WAS IN THE PASSENGER SEAT AND TEAT SHE ( ) WAS IN THE MIDDLE. I ASKED BUM= SOW HE WAS ABLE TO HAVE INTERCOURSE . ' IN THAT POSITION .... ...-- --....._.. - -••••*** ••• '' • • - • • printed by nylons YO II 4041 ea Weeny 07, 2007 01 ... •••--• — • -••••• ••••- — ' ••- • ••• •-••••••••- .... http:llogs.pbso.urg/index,aim' fa-dspC'asc& fromree= I ttsrbta 4h1tIblIc2888a25c-91)2CAE... 217a007 EFTA01158683 OQS - Viewing Case Number 98041883 Page 14 of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE CASE NO. 98041883 SUPPLEMENT 6 oFFENSE REPORT CASE 110. DISPOSITION: OPEN AND HE AT THIS POINT ASKED WHAT THIS (INTERVIEW) WAS ABOUT BEFORE WE CARRIED ON ANY FURTHER. I TOLD HIM MADE A REPORT TEAT NE AND N RAPED HER AND I EXPLAINED I WAS ATTEMPTING TO GET THE STATEMENTS FROM HE AND AS TO EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED. AT THAT POINT. KEVIN TOLD NI HAS SLEPT AROUND. I ASKED BONNER IF SHE ( HAD CLOTHES ON AND HE SAID SHE HAD PANTS AND A SHIRT ON. I ASKED HIM HOW HE WAS ABLE TO HAVE SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH HER WITH HER CLOTHES ON AND HE SAID THAT SHE TOOK THEM OFF. JOSH INDICATED THAT WAS ON TOP OF HIM AT ONE POINT DURING THE SEXUAL INTERCOURSE. I ASKED JOSH BONNER WHAT WAS DOING AT THAT POINT AND HE SAID " I ASKED JOSH BONNER WHAT HE WITNESSED BETWEEN AND HE SAID I ASKED JOSH IF TOLD NO OR TO STOP AND HE REPLIED SHE DID NOT. I ASKED JOSH WHAT HE MEANT BE THE STATEMENT ABOUT STOPPING THE SEX QUICKLY AND HE REPLIED ". I ASKED JOSH NOW AND ENDED UP HAVING SEXUAL INTERCOURSE AND HE REPLIED I ASKED JOSH BONNER HOW AND WERE POSITIONED AND HE SAID I ASKED JOSH IP FORCED INTERCOURSE AND HE REPLIED I ASKED HM IF HE WAS SURE AND SOW HE KNEW THAT AND HE SAID I ASKED JOSH IF A HAD SEX WITH HE AT THE SAME TINE I ASKED JOSH IF HE SAW AND HAVING ORAL SEX AND HE SALE. - I ASKED JOSH WHAT HIS DEFINITION or SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WAS AND HE SAIC. I ASKED JOSH WHAT HIS DEFINITION OF ORAL SEX MOULD SE AND HE SAID " I TOLD JOSH WHEN I USED THE TERM ORAL SEX THAT / MEAN IN REGARDS TO A FEMALE WOULD BE HER POTTING HER MOUTH ON A PENIS AND IN REGARDS TO A MALE IT WOULD BE HIM PUTTING HIS MOUTH ON A VAGINA. I AWED HIM IF HE UNDERSTOOD THAT AND HE SAID THAT HE DID. I ASKED JOSH PERFORMED ORAL SEX ON AND HE REPLIED I ASKED JOSH ' • pERFORMED ORAL SEX ON . 1 AND HE REPLIED " I ASKED JOSH IF A PERFORMED ORAL SEX ON HIM AND HE REPLIED I ASEED JOSH IF HE PERFORMED ORAL SEX ON • ' 1 AND HE ........ ---- • printed OF Arlon* 74 ft: 4541 cc rebsarr 07, 2007 02. .. . ..— • ••••--•••—•-• him:Bons.pbso.orglind ex .efin" fa—dsoCasc&fromrec=18csrlua-4bldbl I c288845c-91)2CAE... 2/7/2007 EFTA01158684 OQS - Viewing Case Number 98041883 Page 15 of 20 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE CASE NO. 98041883 SUPPLEMENT 6 OFFENSE REPORT CASK NO. DISPOSITION: OPEN REPLIED NO. I WENT OFF TAPE AT 4:06PN TO LOOK OVER THE REPORT. I WENT SACK ON TAPE AT 4:09PN AND I DID NOT ASK JOSHEUNNER ANY QUESTIONS OFF TAPE AND WHEN WE WERE BACK ON TAPE I ASKED HIM IF THIS WAS TRUE AND HE CONFIRMED THAT NO QUESTIONS WERE ASKED OFF TAPE. I ALSO RE-CONFIRMED WITH JOSH BOAR THAT HE COULD TERMINATE THE INTERVIEW AT ANY TIME. I ASKED JOSH BONIER IF HE REMEMBERED HE AND PICKING AT HER BOYFRIEND'S HOUSE AND HZ DID NOT REMEMBER. I ASKED JOSH IF HE SAID EARLIER IN THIS INTERVIEW THAT ALMOST PASSED OuT AND HE SAID I AGAIN ASKED JOSH IF HE REMEMBERED ROW MANY BEERS HAD AND RE REPLIED NO. I ALSO ASKED JOSH IF HE ENEW HOW OLD WAS AND HE REPLIED NO. I ASKED JOSH IF HE HAD ANY RECOLLECTION IF WAS ON HER PERIOD AND HE SAID HE HAD NO RECOLLECTION. I ASE® JOSH BUNKER HOW MANY TIMES HE HAD SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH AND HE REPLIED " HE SAID ONE (ECNOUNTER) HAPPENED IN THE FRONT SEAT AND ONE (ENCOUNTER) HAPPENED IN HIS ROOK AT HIS HOUSE AFTER THEY LEFT THE WOODED AREA. JOSH BONIER THEN SAID ". I REMINDED JOSH THAT I HAD ANSWERED THAT QUESTION EARLIER AND I AGAIN WENT ON TO TELL RIM THAT REPORTED THAT SHE WAS RAPED BY HE AND THOMPSON. I ASKED JOSH IF HE REMEMBERED ME TELLING HIM THAT EARLIER IN THE INTERVIEW AND HE REPLIED AGAIN, I ASKED JOSH BUNKER IF HE HAD ANY MEMORY OF FORCING SEXUAL INTERCOURSE ON AND HE SAID , I WAS PRETTY INTOXICATED MYSELF, ". I ASKED