EFTA01111123.pdf

Filing Ii 37557658 E-Filed 02/08/2016 06:20:47 PM IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 17th JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA CIVIL DIVISION BRADLEY J. EDWARDS, and CASE. NO. CACE 15-000072 PAUL G. CASSELL, Plaintiffs, v. ALAN DERSHOWITZ, Defendant. RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT ALAN DERSHOWITZ'S MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION OF CONFIDENTIALITY ORDER OR RELIEF FROM THAT ORDER Non-Party , by and through undersigned counsel, hereby responds to Defendant Alan Dershowitz's Motion for Clarification of Confidentiality Order or Relief From that Order and states as follows: FACTUAL BACKGROUND On November 12, 2015 this Court issued an Order granting in part, non-party IM ; Motion to Quash the subpoena served by Defendant Alan Dershowitz and ordered protective limits relating to her deposition. See Exhibit A, November 12, 2015 Order. On December 18, 2016, this Court entered a Confidentiality Order holding that non-part deposition would be confidential. See Exhibit B, December 18, 2015 Confidentiality Order. On January 16, 2016, Ms=testified at her deposition in accordance with this Court's Order. The deposition was labelled confidential in accordance with this Court's Order. As the Court knows, Ms. was a victim of sexual trafficking when she was a minor child. Indeed, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida has specifically recognized *** FILED: BROWARD COUNTY. FL HOWARD FORMAN. CLERK 2/8/2016 6:20:46 PM EFTA01111123 her as a "victim" of federal sex offenses. Unsurprisingly, her deposition contains highly sensitive infonnation about her experiences as a minor child, including detail descriptions of sexual crimes committed against her. ARGUMENT 1. Non-Party Agrees That Her Deposition Should Be Provided Confidentially To Law Enforcement to Investigate All The Crimes Committed Against Her Defendant Dcrshowitz seeks to have the Court grant an exception to the confidential nature of the deposition so that it can be provided to the Office of the State Attorney and the Office of the United States Attorney for investigative purposes. Specifically, Defendant Dcrshowitz states in his motion that he is hoping to have law enforcement investigate whether ommitted Ms.a perjury by stating in her previously filed affidavit that it is her recollection that she witnessed former President Bill Clinton on Jeffrey Epstein's island in the United States Virgin Islands ('USVI- )1. Setting aside Defendant Dershowitz's baseless claims of perjury, Ms agrees that her confidential deposition should be provided to law enforcement, including the United States Attorney and the State Attorney in each jurisdiction where any alleged crimes occurred so that they may investigate all of the crimes committed against her when she was a minor child. To ensure that justice is served and that Defendant Dershowitz's request is not just another charade designed only to bully a sexual abuse victim, Ms a l sks the Court to impose the following reasonable conditions relating to the disclosure: • Mr. Dcrshowitz agrees and is directed to cooperate with authorities and answer all questions relating to the investigation of crimes against Ms. Defendant Dcrshowitz conveniently ignores that publicly available flight logs of Jeffrey Epstein's private planes demonstrate that President Clinton travelled with Jeffrey Epstein and others to various locations throughout the world including Europe, Africa and Asia. See Exhibit C, Excerpts of Flight Logs from Jeffrey Epstein's private plane. EFTA01111124  • Mr. Dershowitz agrees to make his client. Jeffrey Epstein. and others with relevant testimony and with whom he has testified he shares a "common interest" — at least Epstein and Maxwell — available to any law enforcement agency reviewing any alleged criminal activities: or in the alternative, to attest to this Court that those necessary witnesses have consented to full cooperation in the investigation Mr. Dershowitz is seeking permission to initiate. • Mr. Dershowitz agrees to waive the statute of limitations in all jurisdictions for any criminal conduct he participated in or was aware of relating to Ms. n io that law enforcement can pursue any necessary charges. Defendant Dershowitz proclaimed that he was willing to waive any statute of limitation for criminal conduct so this should not be an issue. See Exhibit D, January 12, 2016 Deposition Transcript of Alan Dershowitz at 395. "I had talked about the statute of limitations for criminal purpose was what I said. that I would waive the statute of limitations for criminal purposes." • Mr. Dershowitz agrees to provide the names and contact information for each State Attorney and United States Attorney for which he has or is planning to rovide information relating to Ms. and agrees to jointly, with Ms. counsel, request that the State Attorney and United States Attorney, in the r isdictions, investigate all potential criminal conduct. Both parties may provide any relevant information they have that may assist the authorities with their investigation. • For all other purposes non-party Ms. January 16, 2016 deposition transcript shall remain confidential and sealed other than for confidential disclosure to law enforcement as described above. 2. Mr. Dershowitz Has No "Evidence" of Perjury And Instead Is Simply Trying To Bully This Victim As explained above, Defendant Dershowitz wrongly suggests to this Court that non-party Virginia has committed perjury in an effort to taint the Court against this victim. His only "evidence" of this alleged perjury is a self-serving opinion from his retained expert that an "absence of records" in response to a FOIA request, establishes that former President Clinton was never on Jeffrey Epstein's island in the USVI. Defendant Dershowitz misrepresents the government's response. The government is only required to conduct a reasonable search of readily accessible records. Accordingly. an "absence of records" response does not mean that records do not exist. It simply means that in the course of the search, no records were found. See Cunningham v. U.S. Dept. ofJustice, 961 F.Supp. 2d 226, 236 (D.C. 2013) (court reasoning that "[t]he adequacy of a search is measured by a standard of reasonableness... The question is not 3 EFTA01111125 whether other responsive records may exist, but whether the search was adequate."); Wilbur v. C.I.A., 355 F.3d 675, 678 (D.C. 2004) (court explaining that "the agency's failure to turn up a particular document, or mere speculation that as yet uncovered documents might exist, does not undermine the determination that the agency conducted an adequate search for the requested records."). Moreover, when dealing with a former President's security detail travel, there are a number of reasons why the government may not disclose those records. As explained above, public flight records from Jeffrey Epstein's private plane show that President Clinton traveled with Jeffrey Epstein on multiple occasions. Nevertheless, if Defendant Dershowitz wants to pursue this issue before the Court, then he needs to produce for deposition testimony in this case and the proposed criminal investigation, the other witnesses that were present on the island at the time former President Clinton was alleged to have visited, including his client Jeffrey Epstein, and Ohislaine Maxwell, to whom he has testified he is party to a joint defense agreement. It is worth noting on that point, that despite Mr. Epstein's counsel's attendance at depositions in this case, and Defendant Dershowitz's claim that Mr. Epstein is still his client, Mr. Epstein has taken extreme measures to avoid being deposed in this case despite being ordered to deposition by this Court. Indeed, it is also noteworthy that during Defendant Dershowitz's recent deposition, counsel for Mr. Edwards and Mr. Cassell asked Defendant Dershowitz the following question: "WallIMM lying when she said Jeffrey Epstein socialized with Bill Clinton during the relevant time period?" Depo Tr. Of Alan Dcrshowitz, Vol. 4, January 12, 2016 at 511. Before Defendant Dershowitz could answer, Mr. Dershowitz's legal counsel interposed an attorney-client privilege objection. Id. Perhaps Mr. Epstein's defense counsel can provide to the Court an appropriate privilege log regarding that objection — and all the communications between Mr. Epstein and Defendant Dershowitz that would have been revealed in answer to that question — so that the Court will have the benefit of a full record in niling on this motion. 4 EFTA01111126  CONCLUSION WHEREFORE, Non-Party respectfully requests that this Court allow a limited release of her confidential deposition transcript to law enforcement subject to the terms set forth above on pages 2-3. Dated: February 8, 2016 Respectfully submitted, BOWS", SCHILLER & FLEXNER 1,1,1) 401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 1200 Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 Telephone: (954) 356-0011 Facsimile: (954) 356-0022 By: /s/Sigrid S. McCawley Sigrid S. McCawley, Esq. Florida Bar No. 129305 Attorneyfor Non-Pan)ill=l1 5 EFTA01111127  CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that on February 8. 2016, a true and correct copy of the foregoing,.. was served by Electronic Mail to the individuals identified below. By: /s/Sigrid S. McCawley Sigrid S. McCawley Thomas E. Scott Jack Scarola SEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART MIT a ra & SHIPLEY, P.A. 111.1.11.. P.A. 2139 Palm Bcachtakcs Blvd. 9150 S. Dadeland Blvd., Suite 1400 West Palm Beach, FL 33409-6601 Attorneyfor Mahal& Richard A. Sim son ary t. or a WILEY REIN, LLP 1776 K Street NW Washington, U.C. 20006 Counselfor Defendant Alan Dershowitz 6 EFTA01111128  Is, 4 \ 4( \ <4( st•tt <it.' • #:•\ *4.< * 4' t * A4 * A4 I A I I s>41 4/ s:,#* oQA 'Ss' `Ss' `Ss' `Ss' 4.o 4/14 c. s:* 44\- ao tge ,,<>%e "t 4 i -s4 i ao s:* •:* a •;* -0 I , , , e'S * * • s s s s, s, COQ COQ sr ,Ps oQA le 'Ss' ••,.1s' 's `Ss `Ss `Ss' ..s4c1 i 4 ,sQ.S>4 \*. 4 s.)4\ -s%k s:,* a <4( si ,<%k s:* EXIIIBIT A 4' • 4.c s ss _,s..,# _.,sbNe' r - s,,---• k ..e...4" - ett14/ 4,4`. cs.it .,ss, •:* ,c*- *se> ••• •"" •• k 4$"4.s. • • I c„,'S3, %St"' • s;$̀..- • s;$̀..- *t's *t's *t's s:„*"" ao • • • • • • s ss ss ss s A‘s s,41 4/ 4,1 4/ e 4kA s-Ne' s-Ne' '7 s,4 \ s7 4.4 •,, • .,, cc 4 si # 4 ,- # a a a a *el • a EFTA01111129  434, 434, 434, ,S7P ,S7P ,S7P •sr .At. _.„511/4,-0 .„14,..4. N,c.5b *,<s4( 4\ k 4\ k 4\ 4\ ., ,c5IN • clitken. • ur (ro ii z X4( '‘'Y N" -e... <•'t-.- <•'t. NN-- wc cl. \-mci• IN<M)FoR A, Nv• Nv• gcs.4 -...0 .,,..s4 -...0 .,,..s4 -...0 ,,,, 4 .. ..-- Bizo0 i) couNkktoR i DA „ c<A4=-• • 4.-, -k:›, •4'. 4 .....A. .....A. .....A. 4ziyir.Divisu,N, ....;\ A ds. ,:-4. ,s7r- _.„5.... _,,,r 4 > s.7 c..7•- -g s.-,>- .., -,,,-- BRADtwkrumutt~ -.‘si N(*(..f.: I 5-0ove# ‘Ss' c, 4( 4 6 (Silte. 1- 4( i 4( C.> 4' .tg` <>4\ 4,' <fi 4 "S.. S> 4' 4 <>0. "S.. # e ,,, c 9. `. .4 $å # # # #. #. elli i ffs. ,t "O "fr -<fr Ss #1.AN IWRSJOVI ct •Ss' grA 4\ i )ente 4"' <, <, 4,4 "fr • -:„<;=.:- 4 > te -.15.`" fl <T\-‘:‘ ` e,<> • ORtkik ON BOIL5,YCIIII.I.ER.A.EXNER I.I,P AND .IAN DOV. NO. 3's NUMONS "sit 4 S. • V») I Atil I SUID3CKNAS OR FÖR PROlt.CTI VE ORDER 4tv‘•4 . c.c..Sts, A A g.K.,C2A A CPA ThisNC , . •.c eomes be ifinle Ctlutt on.s# S,Sktinber 2. 204,5;upon Bo' • S air K: H R:lev...j-sr c s≥ N , Sk •,>" 2.... . _.0,;\ ' 4.4 ( ._,...,. 0.f.Plk:ktiticite ctitias4illpteör kt31s4'roti.idt: Oktåand . i)z• I hi: Ni• : -s.-.‘tion.i.ii .., ,c.„, .. yuaskt ..ct• ct -e-- si',.st' # 1. „.(•,I' '' '4> %,`'S'S' '4> %,`'S'S' '4> •;;i•-• ,-"- ••kz'" 1:::› 4 > -SY. Subpo4f5r For Prolciok Order. .,..<, dct,,Cb ,..(‘,":"Y. 14/.(sX:».. _,.(.‘",4 5. 4‘4>< ,..(‘, KC‘CS(' ,c(sP ' 'kl? - "*" .N.:' '' ,"- 'x'•:- •• ••>' '' •••"' Not I lavin!. revieNsed the record und being otlierwise full) ad% ked. the Court herebv Orders: A - .25-X A A C.S, .c.\\Y• 4 .-\ I. »ur-Pany I.ave ikkuctStlies. Selii0 Flexner l.kei 4 \ C§k.k 4 4' . StAlcition to tirik:115 Stibpoena i • \.9 ',y c, '‘‘'...". is. ,c..., .e:ts... Gi . i0 , iwk, cjc 4 k 4 'dt 4 3.‘ lit Okt SI ;nit • 4 4\‘ • thia:t 4 ( • • blek, 4f (P I.U4is 4 (.% qintsjfm :n ikke iret4C.> f - t,. .cs. k. 4' 4 N.C.> 4' k..'" N' Szy 4 .1 es%,"' <s't• 4 ":‘,'^ '4 '' ":‘,'^ 4 ":‘,'^ ‘‘,-,,- St‘, •Cs:" . .Oe „14/ s. Non-Part. kittDoe Xo. 3.k1 4/ %:on to Quasktt wocita or Ikt4S roteeiik e Ord1 4 /1:t.• ". ",4 .4 , 4 > 4 > 4 > 4 > • -4> --,•7 Delliekkill Pan. (intitteikIn part, as foltAsks: A A A A cst ''N ''S' <>Sk ^Sni. The Nlo*to <>Sk _,C.55 iash is 991Tted as to Reinitkts Nos. 9. 174 -'20, und 23. %lit' c..9 c" c"',y c" A r% Ctit <g r% Ctit. 4b AO ‘ .C‘,3k‘-‘1 4/ A A % A e ,S,„ mpron *Ny *Ny ds. • C5s. csks. c„.4 k1 4/ b. A gatientiiiiiiy Qgtit shull criwitet: • • CA-•XfIle ;inkpf Jane Dec NL,4;rshall Ile lintiketo koms NN prejudiec ecskA aRA cs≥- Siv „1 4/ .k> o ttuti: in Lke rem • 4 o o<k* 4 ' N' s\\? ‘$)11 hy Ll• '•'‘,1`0:1 ‘‘ S," esekit??..:11kttrness.tiik e.• ••••$". 4 :> ssN"." 4<s• 044 ~4 Æ14/ s. Seller (K: Flexnerkti.P. '0?" Not A A A e rt e/ S e rt <>#' <>#' 4 . i k< : • i It i 4 <>e' 4s. 4s. 4s. 44s. 44 4 EFTA01111130  ecikA ,ecikA ,ecikA s>v • 4 \ s4* t • k:hall Itty a s 4 <llte I kittdac0 esenethe *•"" •:„'sát •S••• ••• ••• ‘•> • $•••• ••••N• ••••N• Ic to rule tkrOsetions. •4.‹. 14 . a Albe 1)efendatit_ • Dershoviit,kt:an piesent kthe • • • c•tt Ot a 2. Tile '1\ Ill be: lielbt: to the issu case I‘ittjet prettidici: t"•-• • I •.( 4* 4( 5,...,4.* 4•<( tise,truttoOregt 4j•( lit 10 wi . • We it.: alltOtal . <( " 0. • • `..• •'•••• ‘t k deterinined_bate special in CC'S. ••• ••• •*•?' 43 IX )XF‘1) ORD' Feglironard Co*. Florida on it day or»%ember, ‘.., S) 2015. S.) • c.) \‘=" '3A <<, < t• cSs <>sq.\ ••:„'s› :„<> • 4> O • 4> • .s>"S> • 4‹. 4‹. 4,4s. 41<ct , • g kid '21 gaa4 I )licit • 4t. • \4t (..kreuit Judge •• •,- otaisel nI l(4.a,:ort.i QQJ <.›`t> G \''=" \''=" .,st „0.it. ce. A. sh;, • -<. zs.<> # „ 4s. 4s. •". 4- • .S. st• \''=" CC OQ aO st• \''=" CC OQ aO st• \''=" CC OQ aO st• \''=" EFTA01111131  4 1* ts ist , - ..„ e'l, ,, , ,,it " . k ci,44\1 4 14/ k cf.' •-w s:4 ao •• k ,c4c 4c. 4. _4c. - a.- a.- • ao • i i 414/ 414/ sPs oQA JQCO4-̀• k 4414/ 4 4\ 4 41 4/ •' # ••6` .is• aO s,'› *e. ,,$` a.- a.- 4c. 4. a.- • kit * 4( ,At „<tc s t- s s A 4 ek <,k-\ ek s\i‘S' _..1 sS c•P sIsk s$N- COQ •Ss• 4 41 4/ k 4 41 4/ k "\,% Cr 4( *4 St . Q\' a 4 •.% \I> t`' C.> a \I> t` t .4e$ • k • k sciz- *- • t t IW B t ait a. i i I e 1s c.t..4.• .4( ct ,4( c.t44- . -k4( c.t.4-`1/4 a a * # •••:.' )• *-i•' 4 \Ca•••:.' )• *i•' 4 \Ca•••:.' )• • •••:$ 4. * 4( 4( 4( 4( . • * * * • • • a Ct ,:tk cif ,:tk cit, ,,,,, ,,,,, ,,,, s.",$ , *, $ a e$' a •$- 4(. .$ it , , , • • • a CO Q aO s:‘,4 aO •ciz- <t-- <c * O CO CA CO CA -kit I -kit .4.• .4-‘ *1> s:‘,4aO sciz- aO sc* * 4c. e"4̀.< • sp 44. s o<ct ao `•'' 44 44( A A 0' `' 0 4‹. EFTA01111132  ‹P ‹P s'P s'P s'P s'P s'P s'P .S.- _, .S.- _, .S.- _, __, k e4-\ k .0-.*It..- 414-",- &i' o-k4 ...es'o-k4 ...es'o-k4 ...es'o-k4 N 0.R.Di7. i 40 IR -4;