EFTA01113079.pdf
dataset_9 pdf 164.0 KB • Feb 3, 2026 • 1 pages
Lhc ;Ntlit jjork Zim co
Mais Oui, Mostly French, Despite
MUSIC REVIEW
Wagnerian Touches
By STEVE SMITH Published: October 6. 2008
Hiroyuki fto for The New York Times
The tenor Frederic Antoun with the soprano Georgia Jarman in a concert performance of Lalo's opera "Le Roi
d'Ys."
Opera is not the American Symphony Orchestra's chief concern, but Leon Botstein, its music director,
has often turned his attention to neglected corners of the repertory. One niche has proved especially
fertile: French opera in the period from Bizet's "Carmen" (1875) to Debussy's "Pelleas et Melisande"
(1902), when Wagner's influence was at its peak. On Friday night at Avery Fisher Hall, the orchestra
offered a concert performance of Edouard Lab's "Roi d'Ys," composed in 1875 and first performed in
1888, at the Opera-Comique in Paris.
The story, inspired by a Breton folk tale, concerns a classic love triangle: the princess Margared,
promised to Karnac, a rival prince, seeks vengeance after Mylio, her true love, marries Rozenn, her
sister. Plot and psychology echo Wagner, but the sound is predominantly French; the choruses in
particular borrow from folk melodies Lab learned from his wife, Julie de Maligny, a Breton contralto
for whom he created the role of Margared.
Dana Beth Miller, singing the part here, wielded a rich, substantial voice that tightened only slightly in
its highest range, along with a winning stage presence that made her character sympathetic even in
extremes of self-involved recklessness. The other standout voice was that of Fr€d€ric Antoun, a
charismatic Canadian tenor, whose sweet, sure tone made Mylio's "Aubade" a special treat.
Georgia Jarman, Eugene Brancoveanu, Curtis Streetman and Andrew Nolen made admirable
contributions in other roles. The Concert Chorale of New York sounded ravishing, and the orchestra
brilliantly captured the radiant colors and vibrant rhythms of this taut, appealing score.
EFTA01113079
Entities
0 total entities mentioned
No entities found in this document
Document Metadata
- Document ID
- 1b71284b-bbcc-4ff1-b107-46dff78c1c98
- Storage Key
- dataset_9/EFTA01113079.pdf
- Content Hash
- 9452b8a568818f3cd0ce59f5f32810e3
- Created
- Feb 3, 2026